Body Corporate Contracts Simplified: How to Change Managers

Feeling trapped in an unsatisfactory management arrangement? You're not alone. Many body corporates across New Zealand struggle with underperforming managers but feel overwhelmed by contract complexity and change processes. This guide demystifies body corporate contracts and provides a clear roadmap for successfully transitioning to better management.

💡 Pro Tip: The Power of Documentation

Start a "management issues log" immediately. Document every problem with dates, impacts, and responses. This evidence becomes invaluable whether negotiating exit terms or justifying change to owners. Courts and tribunals rely heavily on contemporaneous documentation.

Whether you're dealing with poor communication, escalating fees without improved service, or simply feeling your building deserves better, understanding your contract is the first step to positive change.

This comprehensive guide breaks down contract terms in plain English, explains your rights, and provides a step-by-step process for changing managers—all while protecting your building's interests throughout the transition.

Understanding Your Current Contract

Body corporate management contracts can seem overwhelming, but they typically follow predictable patterns. Knowing what to look for empowers better decisions.

Locating Your Contract

First challenge: finding the actual contract. Many committees discover they're working from assumptions rather than documented agreements.

Where to Find Your Contract:

• Body corporate records: Should be in official minute books or files
• Current manager: Must provide copy upon request
• Previous AGM minutes: Often attached when last renewed
• Committee members: Previous chairs often retain copies

🚨 Red Flag: If your manager can't promptly provide a copy of your current contract, this itself indicates poor administration and record-keeping.

Typical Resolution Requirements:

Contract Types

1. Fixed-Term Contracts

• Specific start and end dates (typically 1-3 years)
• Automatic renewal clauses common
• Requires notice to prevent auto-renewal
• Most common type in New Zealand

2. Rolling/Continuing Contracts

• No fixed end date
• Continue until terminated by either party
• Usually require notice period (typically 3 months)
• More flexibility but less certainty

3. Expired/Implied Contracts

• Original contract term ended but service continues
• Operating on "implied" terms
• Generally easier to terminate
• Common in older buildings

Essential Contract Elements

Since the 2024 Unit Titles Act amendments, all body corporate management contracts must include:

1. Performance reporting requirements
2. Code of conduct compliance
3. Performance review procedures
4. Clear termination grounds and process
5. General meeting role definitions
6. Record return procedures

Important Update: Since May 2024, all body corporate management contracts must include specific mandatory terms including performance standards, termination procedures, and code of conduct compliance. Older contracts should be reviewed and updated.

When to Consider Changing Managers

Recognizing when change is needed can be challenging, especially when problems develop gradually. Here are clear indicators that it's time to explore alternatives:

Financial Warning Signs

• Escalating fees without service improvements: Annual increases exceeding inflation without clear justification
• Hidden charges: Unexpected fees for basic services that should be included
• Poor financial reporting: Late, unclear, or inaccurate financial statements
• Contractor kickbacks suspected: Unusually high quotes from "preferred" suppliers
• Inadequate budget preparation: Consistent over or under-budgeting

Fee Reasonableness Check:

Professional management typically costs 10-15% of your total body corporate budget. If management fees exceed 20% without premium services, investigate alternatives.

Service Delivery Issues

• Poor communication: Slow responses, unreturned calls, missing updates
• Meeting problems: Disorganized AGMs, late minutes, poor preparation
• Maintenance neglect: Reactive rather than proactive approach
• High staff turnover: Constantly dealing with new account managers
• Technology gaps: No online portals, poor record keeping systems

Compliance Failures

• Insurance lapses: Late renewals risking coverage gaps
• Regulatory non-compliance: Missing filing deadlines, inadequate records
• Trust account concerns: Delayed or missing audit reports
• Meeting irregularities: Not following Unit Titles Act requirements

⚠️ Critical: Compliance failures can expose committee members to personal liability. Document these issues immediately and seek legal advice if serious breaches occur.

Relationship Breakdown

• Dismissive attitude: Treating committee as nuisance rather than client
• Conflict of interest: Favouring certain owners or contractors
• Resistance to change: Blocking committee initiatives
• Trust erosion: Pattern of broken promises or misleading information

Key Contract Terms Explained

Understanding these critical clauses empowers informed decisions about your management arrangements:

Termination Clauses

What to Look For:

• Notice period: Usually 3 months, but can range from 1-6 months
• Notice timing: Some require notice before contract anniversary
• Written notice requirements: Specific format and delivery method
• Grounds for termination: "Without cause" vs specific breach requirements

Typical Termination Clause:

"Either party may terminate this agreement by giving not less than three (3) months written notice to expire on or after the end of the initial term."

Translation: You must give 3 months notice, and it can only end after the initial contract period (e.g., first year) is complete.

Automatic Renewal Provisions

The Trap to Avoid:

Many contracts automatically renew unless you actively terminate within a specific window.

Common Auto-Renewal Clause:

"This agreement shall automatically renew for successive one-year terms unless either party provides written notice of non-renewal at least 90 days before the current term expires."

Impact: Miss the 90-day window and you're locked in for another full year.

💡 Action: Calendar reminders 6 months and 4 months before contract anniversary to review and decide on renewal.

Fee Adjustment Mechanisms

Understanding Increases:

• CPI adjustments: Automatic inflation-based increases
• Fixed percentages: Pre-agreed annual rises (e.g., 3%)
• Negotiated increases: Requires agreement each year
• Performance-based: Tied to service level achievements

Watch for: Compound increases that seem small annually but add up significantly over time.

Service Scope Definitions

What's Actually Included?

Vague service descriptions lead to disputes and extra charges. Look for specific lists of included services:

✓ Clear Scope

• Prepare and issue AGM notices
• Attend all general meetings
• Prepare annual budgets
• Issue levy notices quarterly
• Maintain statutory records

✗ Vague Scope

• "General administration"
• "Meeting support as required"
• "Financial management"
• "Statutory compliance"
• "Other duties as needed"

Exit Strategies & Termination Options

Once you've decided change is necessary, choosing the right exit strategy protects your building's interests:

Option 1: Standard Notice Termination

The Straightforward Approach

Using contractual notice provisions for planned transition:

• Advantages: Clear process, time for smooth transition, maintains relationships
• Disadvantages: Must wait out notice period, continued fees during transition
• Best for: Most situations where immediate change isn't critical

Steps for Notice Termination:

1. Review contract for exact notice requirements
2. Obtain committee/owner approval for change
3. Draft formal termination notice
4. Send via required method (registered mail, etc.)
5. Retain proof of delivery
6. Begin transition planning immediately

Option 2: Termination for Breach

When Performance Fails

Ending contract due to manager's failures:

• Grounds: Material breach of contract terms, negligence, non-performance
• Process: Document breaches, provide opportunity to remedy, then terminate
• Advantages: Potentially immediate termination, may avoid penalties
• Risks: Potential disputes, need strong documentation

Evidence Needed:

• ☐ Written complaints and manager responses
• ☐ Examples of specific contract breaches
• ☐ Financial impact documentation
• ☐ Timeline of issues and remediation attempts
• ☐ Committee meeting minutes discussing problems

Option 4: Section 140 Application (Harsh or Unconscionable Contracts)

The Nuclear Option for Unfair Contracts

For contracts entered during the "control period" (when developer controlled the body corporate):

• Legal basis: Section 140(5) of Unit Titles Act 2010
• Requirements: Contract must be "harsh or unconscionable" - near "outrageous"
• Key factors courts consider:
  • Excessive term length (e.g., 3 x 10-year terms)
  • Ultra vires provisions (beyond body corporate powers)
  • Unequal termination rights
  • Combination of oppressive terms
• Process: Court application required - seek legal advice

Key Case: Body Corporate 39611 v Sentinel Management Limited [2012]

Court terminated 30-year management agreement due to combination of excessive length, intrusive powers, and unequal termination provisions. Set precedent for contractual fairness.

Step-by-Step Process for Changing Managers

A systematic approach ensures smooth transition while maintaining building operations:

Phase 1: Preparation (Months 1-2)

1. Document Current Issues

• Compile specific examples of problems
• Calculate financial impact of poor management
• Survey owner satisfaction levels
• Review current contract thoroughly

2. Build Committee Consensus

• Present findings at committee meeting
• Agree on decision to explore change
• Appoint sub-committee if needed
• Set timeline and budget for process

3. Research Alternative Managers

• Identify 3-5 potential replacements
• Request information packages
• Check references and credentials
• Arrange presentations/interviews

Phase 2: Decision Making (Month 3)

4. Evaluate Options

• Compare proposals objectively
• Consider transition support offered
• Assess cultural fit with building
• Verify insurance and credentials

5. Make Recommendation

• Committee selects preferred manager
• Prepare detailed comparison for owners
• Draft resolution for general meeting
• Plan communication strategy

Phase 3: Owner Approval (Month 4)

6. Owner Approval Process

• Check requirements: Review rules for voting thresholds
• Standard requirement: Usually ordinary resolution (simple majority)
• Some contracts: May require special resolution (75%)
• Build support: One-on-one owner discussions often crucial

7. General Meeting

• Present recommendation professionally
• Allow thorough discussion
• Vote on change resolution
• Document decision properly

Phase 4: Implementation (Months 5-6)

8. Formal Notifications

• Send termination notice to current manager
• Confirm appointment with new manager
• Notify all stakeholders of change
• Update contact information

9. Transition Management

• Coordinate records transfer
• Arrange financial handover
• Update banking authorities
• Transfer digital assets/access

Overcoming Owner Resistance to Change

Change can be daunting, especially for owners unfamiliar with the process. Address these common concerns to build support:

Common Fears and How to Address Them

Fear: "It's too complicated"

Reality: The process is straightforward when properly managed

Response: "We've created a clear timeline and the new manager will handle most of the transition work. Your involvement is minimal—just one vote at the meeting."

Support: Provide simple FAQ sheet and offer to answer questions individually

Fear: "Disruption to building operations"

Reality: Professional transitions are seamless

Response: "Daily operations continue uninterrupted. The new manager shadows the old during handover. You won't notice any service gaps."

Evidence: Share examples from other buildings that changed successfully

Fear: "Better the devil you know"

Reality: Poor management costs money and creates problems

Response: "We're currently paying $X for substandard service. Other buildings with professional management pay less and get more. Here's the evidence..."

Data: Show cost comparisons and service level differences

Fear: "Legal complications"

Reality: Contracts are designed to be terminated

Response: "We've reviewed our contract and followed legal requirements. The new manager also provides transition support to ensure compliance."

Reassurance: Consider legal review for complex situations

Building Support Strategies

Create Champions

• Identify influential owners who share concerns
• Involve them early in the process
• Have them speak at meetings
• Use their networks to build support

Use Numbers Effectively

• Show financial benefits clearly
• Compare service levels objectively
• Highlight missed opportunities under current management
• Project savings over 3-5 years

Address Individual Concerns

• One-on-one conversations with hesitant owners
• Tailored information for different owner types
• Patient explanation of benefits
• Respect for different perspectives

Managing a Smooth Transition

The transition period determines whether your change decision succeeds. Professional handling ensures continuity:

Critical Handover Elements

Records Transfer

• ☐ All financial records (minimum 7 years)
• ☐ Meeting minutes and resolutions
• ☐ Contracts and agreements
• ☐ Insurance policies and claims history
• ☐ Maintenance records and warranties
• ☐ Owner contact database
• ☐ Compliance certificates

Financial Transition

• ☐ Bank account signatories update
• ☐ Final financial reconciliation
• ☐ Outstanding levy collection status
• ☐ Creditor payment arrangements
• ☐ Financial audit if required

Operational Continuity

• ☐ Contractor notifications
• ☐ Insurance broker introduction
• ☐ Emergency contact updates
• ☐ Key and access code transfers
• ☐ Utility account management

Communication During Transition

Stakeholder Updates

Setting Expectations

Realistic Timeline

• Week 1-2: Initial setup and orientation
• Month 1: Systems establishment and learning
• Month 2-3: Relationship building and optimization
• Month 4-6: Full operational efficiency

Remember: Even the best managers need time to understand your building's unique needs. Allow 3-6 months before expecting transformational changes.

Common Pitfalls to Avoid

Learn from others' mistakes to ensure your transition succeeds:

Legal Pitfalls

❌ Improper Termination

• Mistake: Verbal notice or informal email
• Risk: Contract continues, potential damages claim
• Solution: Follow contract requirements exactly, use registered mail

❌ Insufficient Authority

• Mistake: Committee terminates without owner approval
• Risk: Invalid termination, personal liability
• Solution: Check constitution/rules for required approvals

❌ Operating Without Written Contract

• Mistake: Continuing with verbal agreements or expired contracts
• Risk: Uncertainty, potential disputes, compliance issues
• Solution: All management arrangements must be documented per 2024 requirements
• Opportunity: Easier to terminate informal arrangements

Financial Pitfalls

❌ Unpaid Fees Dispute

• Mistake: Withholding payment due to poor service
• Risk: Legal action, damaged credit
• Solution: Pay under protest, document issues separately

❌ Hidden Termination Costs

• Mistake: Not budgeting for transition expenses
• Risk: Special levy required
• Solution: Include transition costs in change proposal

Operational Pitfalls

❌ Lost Records

• Mistake: Not securing all documents before termination
• Risk: Missing critical information
• Solution: Complete records audit before notice

❌ Ignoring MBIE's New Powers

• Mistake: Not considering regulatory oversight in disputes
• Risk: Missing enforcement opportunities
• Reality: MBIE can now issue improvement notices, require documents, and monitor compliance
• Solution: Consider regulatory complaint for serious breaches

Keys to Successful Manager Change

1. Professional Approach

• Treat current manager respectfully despite issues
• Focus on business needs, not personalities
• Document everything properly
• Maintain confidentiality during selection

2. Clear Communication

• Keep all owners informed throughout
• Address concerns promptly and honestly
• Provide regular progress updates
• Celebrate successful transition

3. Thorough Planning

• Allow adequate time for each phase
• Have contingency plans ready
• Budget for unexpected costs
• Maintain focus on long-term benefits

Regional Considerations

Contract terms and transition processes can vary by location:

Auckland Considerations

• Competitive market: Multiple quality managers available
• Quick transitions: Experienced managers handle handovers efficiently
• Higher expectations: Technology and service standards advanced
• Contract variety: More negotiation flexibility

Wellington Factors

• Insurance expertise crucial: Ensure new manager has earthquake insurance experience
• Smaller market: Fewer managers but closer relationships
• Compliance focus: Seismic assessments require specialist knowledge
• Cost pressures: Insurance costs may limit management budgets

Christchurch Context

• Post-earthquake expertise: EQC claim experience valuable
• Newer contracts: Many updated post-earthquake
• Technical requirements: Building compliance knowledge essential
• Collaborative approach: Closer manager-committee relationships common

Real-World Change Scenarios

Learn from these common situations:

Scenario 1: The Auto-Renewal Trap

Situation: Committee discovers their contract auto-renewed for 3 years just before planning to change managers.

Solution: Negotiated early exit by demonstrating mutual benefit. New manager assisted with transition planning, making it attractive for outgoing manager to cooperate.

Lesson: Calendar contract dates well in advance and review termination requirements annually.

Scenario 2: The Missing Contract

Situation: No one can find the current management contract. Manager claims 5-year term with 2 years remaining.

Solution: Requested contract copy formally. When manager couldn't produce, treated as month-to-month arrangement and terminated with standard notice.

Lesson: Missing documentation often indicates poor management and may simplify termination.

Scenario 3: The Performance Termination

Situation: Manager failed to renew insurance on time, leaving building exposed for two weeks.

Solution: Documented breach, provided opportunity to respond, then terminated for material breach when explanation was inadequate.

Lesson: Serious compliance failures justify immediate action but still require proper process.

Take Control of Your Body Corporate's Future

Changing body corporate managers doesn't have to be overwhelming. With clear understanding of your contract, systematic planning, and professional support, you can transition to management that truly serves your building's needs.

Key Takeaways:

• Understanding your current contract is the essential first step
• Document problems and build support before initiating change
• Follow proper termination procedures to avoid legal issues
• Allow adequate time for smooth transition (typically 3-6 months)
• Address owner concerns with facts and clear communication
• Professional managers facilitate seamless handovers

Is It Time for Change?

If you recognize multiple warning signs—escalating costs without service improvements, poor communication, compliance failures, or breakdown in trust—it's time to explore alternatives.

Remember: You're not stuck with inadequate management. Your contract includes termination provisions specifically because the relationship may need to change as your building's needs evolve.

Experience the Royce Difference

Transitioning to new management should enhance, not disrupt, your building operations. At Royce, we've perfected the art of seamless transitions.

Our Transition Promise:

• ✓ Comprehensive transition planning from day one
• ✓ No service interruptions during handover
• ✓ Clear communication with all stakeholders
• ✓ Technology-enabled efficient processes
• ✓ Transparent contracts with fair terms
• ✓ Local expertise in Auckland, Wellington & Christchurch

‍